The treatment options for patients requiring repair of a long segment of the urethra are limited by the availability of autologous tissues. We previously reported that acellular collagen-based tubularized constructs seeded with cells are able to repair small urethral defects in a rabbit model.
We explored the feasibility of engineering clinically relevant long urethras for surgical reconstruction in a canine preclinical model.
Design, setting, and participants
Autologous bladder epithelial and smooth muscle cells from 15 male dogs were grown and seeded onto preconfigured collagen-based tubular matrices (6
Outcome measurements and statistical analysis
Statistical analysis of CT imaging and histology was not needed.
Results and limitations
CT urethrograms showed wide-caliber urethras without strictures in animals implanted with cell-seeded matrices. The urethral segments replaced with acellular scaffolds collapsed. Gross examination of the urethral implants seeded with cells showed normal-appearing tissue without evidence of fibrosis. Histologically, an epithelial cell layer surrounded by muscle fiber bundles was observed on the cell-seeded constructs, and cellular organization increased over time. The epithelial and smooth muscle phenotypes were confirmed using antibodies to pancytokeratins AE1/AE3 and smooth muscle–specific desmin. Formation of an epithelial cell layer occurred in the unseeded constructs, but few muscle fibers formed.
Cell-seeded tubularized collagen scaffolds can be used to repair long urethral defects, whereas scaffolds without cells lead to poor tissue development and strictures. This study demonstrates that long tissue-engineered tubularized urethral segments may be used for urethroplasty in patients.
Keywords: Urethra, Stricture repair, Cell-seeded tubularized urethra reconstruction, Tissue-engineered urethra.
Repair of the anterior urethra is one of the most demanding surgical problems in urology. A multitude of techniques have been used to treat anterior urethral strictures using buccal mucosa or a penile skin flap for reconstruction  and . However, in many cases, an adequate amount of penile skin is not available . In such circumstances, surgeons have been forced to use other externalization techniques such as perineal urethrotomy.
In recent years, regenerative medicine and tissue engineering studies have led to the development of novel biomaterials for urethral repair such as decellularized collagen matrices and synthetic polymers , , , , and . These advances have provided the ability to engineer tubularized tissue constructs for the successful management of urethral stricture. Although these materials are biocompatible and facilitate tissue regeneration by bridging tissue defects, studies have shown that the maximum distance of tissue regeneration is limited  and . Also, it has been demonstrated that acellular collagen scaffold materials are unsuitable for tubularized urethral reconstruction because they collapse and lead to further stricture  and .
However, recent studies indicate that seeding a tubular urethral scaffold with autologous cells can lead to successful repair of urethral defects  and . This study used a synthetic polymer scaffold for this purpose, and although the construct was able to bridge urethral defects, the stiffness and biocompatibility of synthetic materials are not entirely optimal for urethral applications.
Collagen constructs derived from the bladder submucosa (lamina propria) have been used as a substrate for urethral repair, either with or without cells , , , and . These matrices are biocompatible, flexible, and easily prepared in large quantities. We previously demonstrated that collagen-based tubularized constructs seeded with cells are able to repair small urethral defects in a rabbit model. In the present study, we investigated the feasibility of using collagen-based seeded grafts to engineer long urethral segments in canines, a more clinically relevant animal model.
2. Materials and methods
This study was conducted with the approval of the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee. A total of 21 male beagle dogs were divided into a control group (6 animals) that received unseeded tubularized acellular bladder matrix (ABM) constructs and a group (15 animals) that received cell-seeded tubularized ABM. Constructs were retrieved at 1, 3, 6, and 12 mo after implantation (Fig. 1).
2.1. Preparation of the acellular bladder matrix
Porcine acellular bladder matrix was processed as described previously . Briefly, the mucosa (urothelium/suburothelium) of the bladder was removed by surgical delamination. The bladder matrix was rinsed with water in a stirring flask (200
2.2. Bladder biopsy
2.3. Cell isolation and expansion
Cells were isolated and expanded according to previously published protocols . The mucosal and muscle layer were mechanically separated. Muscle fragments were placed on culture dishes, and muscle cells were expanded from these explants in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle Medium (DMEM, Sigma Aldrich, St. Louis, MO, USA) supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (Gibco, Grand Island, NY, USA). The urothelial layer was mechanically separated from the bladder tissue using a scalpel, and the cells were expanded in a similar manner in Keratinocyte Serum-Free Medium (KSFM, Gibco). Each cell culture required an average of five to six passages to reach appropriate numbers for seeding and implantation. Prior to seeding, the urothelial cells were labeled with PKH 26 (red dye) and the muscle cells were labeled with PKH 67 (green dye). Cell labeling was confirmed by fluorescent microscopy prior to the seeding process.
2.4. Scaffold preparation and cell seeding
Each scaffold was sterilized and tubularized by suturing a 7-cm-long segment of the decellularized bladder matrix around a 14F sterile urethral catheter under aseptic conditions. For the control group, the scaffold was incubated for 24
2.5. Surgical procedure
Under anesthesia, a suprapubic bladder catheter was surgically inserted into the bladder and left in place for 4 wk postoperatively to ensure proper drainage of urine during healing. Subsequently, the bulbar and proximal penile urethra was exposed and dissected through an inverted Y-shaped perineal incision. A 6-cm-long segment of urethra starting distal to the membranous urethra was transected and removed. The cell-seeded urethral scaffold was interposed and its ends were anastomosed with the native ends of urethral tissues using 6/0 Vicryl sutures. The wound was closed in layers in a routine fashion. Gentle compression was applied to the surgical wound. The bandage was kept in place for 3 d before reapplication whenever possible. Analgesia (buprenorphine, 0.01
The urethral tubes were left in place for 3–4 wk whenever possible. Upon removal, retrograde and voiding computed tomography (CT) urethrocystography (Toshiba 32-slice Aquilion scanner) was performed. The CT study was repeated at 1, 3, 6, and 12 mo after surgery. The suprapubic catheter was closed at the time of urethral stent removal and was removed 1 wk later in all experimental animals. In the control group, removal of the suprapubic catheter depended on the degree of patency of the urethra.
The experimental animals that received cell-seeded urethral constructs (n
3.1. In vitro analysis
The processed collagen-based scaffolds showed the presence of extracellular matrices with absence of cells, as evidenced by histomorphologic analysis (Fig. 2). The decellularized scaffolds were assessed for acellularity using DNA quantification. DNA quantification showed an average of 0.206–0.244 ng/mg DNA in the acellular bladder matrix, which is within acceptable limits (<0.3 ng/mg) for decellularized materials. Successful cell cultures were obtained from every bladder biopsy used in the study. Bladder epithelial and smooth muscle cells were grown and expanded separately until sufficient numbers of cells were obtained. Both the urothelial and smooth muscle cells showed expression of AE1/AE3 and desmin, respectively (Fig. 3). Prior to implantation, a 1-cm piece of every seeded scaffold was removed for testing to ensure proper seeding of the cells. All scaffolds showed attachment of multilayered urothelial cells in the inner layer and muscle cells on the outer surface of the construct (Fig. 4).
3.2. Surgical outcomes
All six control animals implanted with acellular matrices resulted in early urine leakage after removal of the urethral stent, which was attributed to fistulae formation at the anastomotic site. All animals in this group developed urethral strictures within 3 mo of implantation as shown via CT urethrocystography, and they were euthanized when voiding became difficult and their urethras were severely obstructed (Fig. 5). Gross anatomic and histologic assessment postmortem showed evidence of stricture formation and fibrosis throughout the entire implanted construct.
All animals in the experimental group (n
Various urethral conditions often require extensive urethral reconstruction for which onlay grafts would not be suitable . A multistage urethroplasty is generally recommended . Many urethral tissue substitutes have been used for tubularized urethroplasties, but they have not been satisfactory and often lead to complications  and . Buccal mucosa remains the most widely used source of tissue for urethral replacement, especially in cases of complex urethral reconstruction. However, anastomotic strictures and fistulas are commonly reported . In addition, when used in a staged procedure, healing of buccal mucosa grafts is not similar in all patients, and multiple revisions of the graft bed may be necessary to obtain a satisfactory urethral bed before closure . Significant donor site morbidity has also been reported after harvesting buccal mucosa  and . Another commonly used graft material is bladder mucosa, which has also been associated with a number of complications including meatal stenosis, prolapse, and a granulomatous reaction at the urethral meatus .
For these reasons, many attempts have been made to identify alternative tissues that would serve as adequate urethral substitutes. Tissue engineering techniques may be a suitable option for the creation of biocompatible urethral tissues . Acellular collagen matrices derived from the bladder have already been successfully applied both experimentally and clinically for urethral repair as an onlay graft  and . However, experimental data have shown that in cases of tubularized urethral replacement, cell seeding is necessary to prevent stricture formation when matrices are used .
In this study, tissue-engineered tubularized grafts seeded with autologous cells were successfully used for the replacement of longer urethral segments and are thus applicable to a number of clinical situations. From a bladder biopsy, we were able to isolate both urothelial and smooth muscle cells and expand them until sufficient numbers for scaffold seeding were obtained. In this study we demonstrate that the urothelial cells formed a multilayered epithelial lining on the luminal side of the scaffold while the muscle cells formed a corresponding layer on the outer surface.
To demonstrate that the seeded cells are able to contribute to tissue formation in vivo, we labeled the cells with a fluorescent marker and followed them in vivo. We showed that both urothelial and smooth muscle cells that were seeded on the implanted scaffolds are able to survive and proliferate in the newly formed tissue until retrieval. Both cell types were shown to contribute significantly to the multilayered tissue structure formed 3 mo after implantation.
Importantly, the animals receiving the cell-seeded tubularized urethral grafts showed improvement over the control group in all histologic and functional aspects. Urothelial coverage and a complete muscle layer were seen in all experimental animals beginning at 1 mo postoperatively. These layers continued to develop and approximate normal tissues throughout the duration of the study, with no abnormal findings. In comparison, the control animals developed at most a single layer of stratified epithelium within 1–3 mo postoperatively. All of these animals developed urethral strictures of either a portion of or the entire implanted scaffold within the first 3 mo. Fistula formation, urine extravasation, and hematoma formation were also noted in all of the control animals; only four of the experimental animals experienced minor complications. These results confirm and supplement our previous study using shorter urethral defects in the rabbit model . We hypothesize that when cell-seeded scaffolds are used, the rapid development of a urothelial barrier along the luminal surface of the urethra may prevent urine leakage into the suburothelial tissue and associated fibrosis. In the control animals, which do not develop a sufficient urothelial layer, urinary irritation may be one of the major factors implicated in the inflammatory infiltration and fibrous tissue deposition that led to stricture formation. Another contributing factor to the success of cell-seeded tubular urethral replacement could be the support provided by the rapidly developing muscle layer that keeps the urethra from collapsing and prevents wall adhesions. This mechanism would not be present in the unseeded scaffolds.
Although this study provides evidence that cell-seeded tubularized scaffolds can be used in the reconstruction of long urethral defects, one limitation may be the small number of experimental animals that were evaluated per time point. Further investigations are necessary to translate this technology into the clinic.
This study provides preclinical evidence that cell-seeded tubularized scaffolds can be used in the reconstruction of long urethral defects. Acellular collagen matrix derived from the bladder combined with autologous cells resulted in the development of normal-appearing urethral tissue layers over time. This study provides some of the information needed to move toward clinical studies of this technique. More studies are required to establish the feasibility of using the same concept for longer and more complicated defects. However, the use of cell-seeded tubularized urethral scaffolds is feasible for defects up to 6–7
Study concept and design: Orabi, AbouShwareb, Zhang, Yoo, Atala.
Acquisition of data: Orabi, Aboushwareb.
Analysis and interpretation of data: Orabi, AbouShwareb, Zhang, Yoo, Atala.
Drafting of the manuscript: Orabi, Yoo, Atala.
Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Yoo, Atala.
Statistical analysis: Orabi, AbouShwareb, Yoo.
Obtaining funding: Yoo, Atala.
Administrative, technical, or material support: Yoo, Atala.
Supervision: Yoo, Atala.
Other (specify): None.
Financial disclosures: Anthony Atala certifies that all conflicts of interest, including specific financial interests and relationships and affiliations relevant to the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript (eg, employment/affiliation, grants or funding, consultancies, honoraria, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, royalties, or patents filed, received, or pending), are the following: None.
Funding/Support and role of the sponsor: Research reported in the article was funded, in part, by the US National Institutes of Health (NIH). Grant number: DK065298-05.
Acknowledgment statement: The authors wish to thank Dr. Jennifer Olson for editorial assistance with this manuscript. We also thank Cindy Andrews, Mandy Lockard, Paul Sikoski, and Sergio Rodriguez for surgical assistance.
-  M. Bhandari, D. Dubey, B.S. Verma. Dorsal or ventral placement of the preputial/penile skin onlay flap for anterior urethral strictures: does it make a difference?. BJU Int. 2001;88:39-43 Crossref.
-  J.K. Quartey. One-stage transverse distal penile/preputial island flap urethroplasty for urethral stricture. Ann Urol (Paris). 1993;27:228-232
-  S.N. Venn, A.R. Mundy. Urethroplasty for balanitis xerotica obliterans. Br J Urol. 1998;81:735-737 Crossref.
-  S. Wu, Y. Liu, S. Bharadwaj, A. Atala, Y. Zhang. Human urine-derived stem cells seeded in a modified 3D porous small intestinal submucosa scaffold for urethral tissue engineering. Biomaterials. 2011;32:1317-1326 Crossref.
-  A. Mangera, C.R. Chapple. Tissue engineering in urethral reconstruction. F1000 Med Rep. 2010;2:65
-  Y. Guan, L. Ou, G. Hu, et al. Tissue engineering of urethra using human vascular endothelial growth factor gene-modified bladder urothelial cells. Artif Organs. 2008;32:91-99 Crossref.
-  C. Li, Y.M. Xu, L.J. Song, Q. Fu, L. Cui, S. Yin. Urethral reconstruction using oral keratinocyte seeded bladder acellular matrix grafts. J Urol. 2008;180:1538-1542 Crossref.
-  Q. Fu, C.L. Deng, W. Liu, Y.L. Cao. Urethral replacement using epidermal cell-seeded tubular acellular bladder collagen matrix. BJU Int. 2007;99:1162-1165 Crossref.
-  R.E. De Filippo, J.J. Yoo, A. Atala. Urethral replacement using cell seeded tubularized collagen matrices. J Urol. 2002;168:1789-1792 discussion 1792–3
-  R.P. Dorin, H.G. Pohl, R.E. De Filippo, J.J. Yoo, A. Atala. Tubularized urethral replacement with unseeded matrices: what is the maximum distance for normal tissue regeneration?. World J Urol. 2008;26:323-326 Crossref.
-  A. Raya-Rivera, D.R. Esquiliano, J.J. Yoo, E. Lopez-Bayghen, S. Soker, A. Atala. Tissue-engineered autologous urethras for patients who need reconstruction: an observational study. Lancet. 2011;377:1175-1182 Crossref.
-  A. el-Kassaby, T. AbouShwareb, A. Atala. Randomized comparative study between buccal mucosal and acellular bladder matrix grafts in complex anterior urethral strictures. J Urol. 2008;179:1432-1436 Crossref.
-  A.W. el-Kassaby, A.B. Retik, J.J. Yoo, A. Atala. Urethral stricture repair with an off-the-shelf collagen matrix. J Urol. 2003;169:170-173 discussion 173
-  S.Y. Chun, G.J. Lim, T.G. Kwon, et al. Identification and characterization of bioactive factors in bladder submucosa matrix. Biomaterials. 2007;28:4251-4256 Crossref.
-  A. Atala, J.P. Vacanti, C.A. Peters, J. Mandell, A.B. Retik, M.R. Freeman. Formation of urothelial structures in vivo from dissociated cells attached to biodegradable polymer scaffolds in vitro. J Urol. 1992;148:658-662
-  D.E. Andrich, T.J. Greenwell, A.R. Mundy. The problems of penile urethroplasty with particular reference to 2-stage reconstructions. J Urol. 2003;170:87-89 Crossref.
-  A.R. Mundy. The long-term results of skin inlay urethroplasty. Br J Urol. 1995;75:59-61 Crossref.
-  G. Barbagli, M. Lazzeri. Urethral reconstruction. Curr Opin Urol. 2006;16:391-395
-  J. Fichtner, D. Filipas, M. Fisch, R. Hohenfellner, J.W. Thuroff. Long-term followup of buccal mucosa onlay graft for hypospadias repair: analysis of complications. J Urol. 2004;172:1970-1972 discussion 1972 Crossref.
-  N. Dublin, L.H. Stewart. Oral complications after buccal mucosal graft harvest for urethroplasty. BJU Int. 2004;94:867-869 Crossref.
-  T.M. Kinkead, P.A. Borzi, P.G. Duffy, P.G. Ransley. Long-term followup of bladder mucosa graft for male urethral reconstruction. J Urol. 1994;151:1056-1058
-  A. Atala, L. Guzman, A.B. Retik. A novel inert collagen matrix for hypospadias repair. J Urol. 1999;162:1148-1151
-  A. Atala. Bioengineered tissues for urogenital repair in children. Pediatr Res. 2008;63:569-575 Crossref.
a Department of Urology and Institute for Regenerative Medicine, Wake Forest School of Medicine, Winston Salem, NC, USA
b Urology Department, Assiut University, Egypt 71516
Corresponding author. Wake Forest Institute for Regenerative Medicine, Wake Forest University Health Sciences, Medical Center Blvd., Winston Salem, NC 27157, USA. Tel. +1 336 716 5701; Fax: +1 336 716 0656.
© 2012 European Association of Urology, Published by Elsevier B.V.