Platinum Priority – Bladder Cancer
Editorial by James W.F. Catto on pp. 37–38 of this issue

Bacillus Calmette-Guérin Without Maintenance Therapy for High-Risk Non–Muscle-Invasive Bladder Cancer eulogo1

By: Harry W. Herrlowast , Guido Dalbagni and Sherri M. Donat

European Urology, Volume 60 Issue 1, July 2011, Pages 32-36

Published online: 01 July 2011

Keywords: Bladder cancer, BCG, Mainetenance

Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF (216 KB)



Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) is the standard intravesical treatment of high-risk noninvasive (Ta, T1, Tis) bladder cancer. Maintenance BCG is recommended for maximum efficacy.


We compared our results in a large cohort of high-risk bladder cancer patients who received BCG without maintenance with published results from randomized maintenance BCG trials.

Design, setting, and participants

A cohort of 1021 patients underwent restaging transurethral resection for high-risk (Ta, T1, Tis) bladder cancer.


Patients received a 6-wk induction course of BCG therapy. Responding patients did not receive maintenance BCG. Relapsing patients were eligible for retreatment with BCG. All patients were followed for a minimum of 5 yr.


End points were 5-yr tumor- and progression-free survival rates.

Results and limitations

Of 816 complete responders to induction BCG, 2- and 5-yr recurrence-free survival rates were 73% and 46%, respectively. The progression-free survival rate was 89%. Progression-free survival time was 56 mo (95% confidence interval, 55–58 mo). Thirty-two percent of the patients required another course of BCG therapy. We cannot exclude that maintenance BCG may benefit patients beyond 5 yr over induction BCG alone and selective BCG retreatments.


Our results with BCG treatment without maintenance of patients with high-risk non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer compare favorably with trials in which comparable patients received maintenance BCG.

Take Home Message

Maintenance bacillus Calmette-Guérin is not necessary in all high-risk patients with non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer.

Keywords: Bladder cancer, BCG, Mainetenance.

1. Introduction

Intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) is the standard treatment after transurethral resection (TUR) of high-risk non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer. Since it was first introduced by Morales et al in 1976 [1], randomized trials have shown that BCG therapy reduces the frequency of tumor recurrences and prevents or delays stage progression better than TUR alone [2] and [3] or topical chemotherapy [4] and [5]. Most practice guidelines recommend maintenance BCG for 1–3 yr [6] and [7], whereas it is optional in others [8]. The widespread use of maintenance BCG is based on a single, albeit large, trial [9], and a meta-analysis of published results from selected trials suggests that tumor progression is reduced only among patients receiving maintenance BCG therapy [10]. However, we showed that induction BCG alone delayed progression and improved 5-yr [11] and 10-yr [12] cancer-specific survival. We also showed that maintenance BCG added no benefit to induction BCG [13], which was confirmed in four subsequent negative randomized trials [14]. Two additional small studies have recently been published; one showed no significant advantage to maintenance BCG [15], whereas the other demonstrated improved recurrence-free survival over induction BCG alone [16]. Adding to the confusion, a recent review did not appear to show significant differences in the cumulative incidence of recurrence or progression between patients receiving BCG alone or BCG with maintenance therapy [17].

Maintenance BCG is associated with cumulative toxicity. Only 16% of patients in the Southwest Oncology Group (SWOG) trial were able to complete the 3-yr maintenance schedule [9], and we found that only 36% of patients were able to tolerate 2 yr of monthly BCG instillations [13]. One study, however, claimed that 80% of patients completed a 3-yr maintenance regimen and only 20% became intolerant [18]. We do not use maintenance BCG because of poor compliance and negative results from the randomized trial in our patient population and prefer to retreat responding patients who later relapse with another 6 wk of BCG, sparing them undue toxicity.

Maintenance BCG benefits only patients who respond to induction BCG. Several reviews, a meta-analysis, and results from randomized multicenter studies were published recently, showing outcomes of responding patients receiving maintenance therapy [19], [20], [21], [22], and [23]. We compare our results in patients with high-risk non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer who were treated with BCG without maintenance.

2. Patients and methods

A cohort of 1021 consecutive patients with bladder cancer was evaluated from 1995 to 2006. They underwent restaging TUR and were found to have high-risk non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer (high-grade Ta, T1, and/or Tis). They then received six weekly instillations of Connaught strain (81mg) BCG therapy and were evaluated for response after 3 and 6 mo by cystoscopy, urine cytology, and TUR biopsy. No patients received maintenance BCG therapy. A complete response was defined as a negative biopsy and urine cytology by 6 mo. Patients were followed every 3–6 mo with cystoscopy, repeat TUR as necessary, and urine cytology. Each patient was entered into a database, and clinical information was updated prospectively at each follow-up evaluation. Patients who recurred with non–muscle-invasive disease after 6 mo were eligible to receive another BCG induction course. Patients who recurred and underwent cystectomy before objective evidence of tumor progression were considered treatment failures. Patients who were upstaged to muscle invasion (T2) on restaging TUR or who underwent immediate cystectomy without receiving BCG were excluded from analysis.

Patients who responded completely to induction BCG are the focus of this report. End points were recurrence-free and progression-free survival. Tumor recurrence was defined as any tumor on biopsy or positive urine cytology during follow-up examinations. Progression was defined as a muscle-invasive tumor or metastasis. We constructed Kaplan-Meier curves for cancer-free survival times. The institutional review board approved the study.

3. Results

Of the 1021 patients evaluated and treated, 816 (79%) had a complete response to induction BCG therapy (784 patients had no tumor at both 3- and 6-mo evaluations, and 32, or 23% of 141 patients positive at 3 mo, became negative by 6 mo without another course of BCG). Table 1 shows the patient and tumor characteristics. They represent a cohort at high risk for tumor recurrence and tumor progression owing to high-grade, high-volume papillary or solid urothelial tumors, often associated with carcinoma in situ. All patients received a 6-wk induction of BCG, and 32% were retreated with another 6-wk course of BCG for tumor relapse during the minimum follow-up period of 5 yr. Sixty-seven patients (8%) underwent cystectomy for recurrent T1 cancers; they are evaluated as treatment failures. Of note, 107 patients (13%) developed upper tract tumors within 5 yr.

Table 1 Patient characteristics

Patients, n 816
Sex, No. (%)
Male 597 (73)
Female 219 (27)
Age, yr
Median (range) 64 (21–93)
Tumor type, No. (%)
Ta 416 (51)
T1 400 (49)
Grade, No. (%)
High grade 780 (96)
Low grade* 36 (4)
Carcinoma in situ (Tis), No. (%)
Yes 505 (62)
No 311 (38)
Disease extent, No. (%)
Solitary/primary 57 (7)
Multiple/primary 90 (11)
Multiple/recurrent** 669 (82)
Restaging TUR pathology, No. (%)
T0 392 (48)
Tis 165 (20)
Ta 192 (24)
T1 67 (8)
Prior intravesical chemotherapy, No. (%)
Yes 155 (19)
No 661 (81)
BCG courses, No. (%)
1 816
2 187 (23)
3 73 (9)
BCG maintenance 0
Minimum follow-up, 5 yr, No. 816

* T1 tumors.

** One or more recurrent tumors within prior 6 mo.

TUR=transurethral resection; BCG=bacillus Calmette-Guérin.

Figure 1 shows the recurrence-free survival of patients who responded initially to induction BCG therapy. The 2-yr recurrence-free survival rate was 73% (221 patients [27%] recurred), and after 5 yr, 46% remained free of recurrence (438 patients [54%] experienced at least one tumor recurrence). The median time to recurrence was 41 mo (95% confidence interval, 39–42 mo).


Fig. 1 Five-year recurrence-free survival of 816 patients after complete response to bacillus Calmette-Guérin therapy.

Figure 2 shows 5-yr progression-free survival among the 816 patients, who were followed for at least 5 yr without maintenance BCG but selectively retreated with a 6-wk course of BCG for noninvasive tumor relapse. Five-year progression-free survival was 89%; 93 patients (11%) progressed. The median time to progression has not been reached. None of the patients progressed between 3 and 6 mo after BCG therapy, and only one progressed to muscle invasion before 12 mo. A total of 33 patients (32% of progressors and 4% overall) died of urothelial cancer.


Fig. 2 Five-year progression-free survival of 816 complete responders to bacillus Calmette-Guérin therapy.

4. Discussion

The major finding of our study is that of 816 patients with high-risk non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer who underwent restaging TUR and had a complete response to induction BCG therapy, 27% recurred within 2 yr and half recurred by 5 yr, 11% progressed, and 4% died of urothelial cancer without receiving maintenance BCG therapy. Maintenance BCG was not used in favor of retreatment with BCG as needed upon relapse, which was required in 32% of patients. The fact that each patient had a second-look TUR may have contributed to the favorable results because the majority had residual disease resected before receiving BCG therapy. Quality of TUR, however, remains an unquantifiable variable and is usually poorly defined in intravesical trials.

How do these results compare with randomized trials using maintenance BCG? We restricted our comparisons to published raw data (provided in tables and figures) from prospective or randomized studies that included high-risk patients who responded initially to induction BCG therapy and then received a maintenance BCG regimen. The SWOG study reported that 56% of patients (108 of 192 on the maintenance arm) had a recurrence (similar to our 54% having recurrences), but they showed 5-yr recurrence-free survival in 60% of patients receiving the three plus three maintenance schedule [9], 14% higher than our 46% 5-yr recurrence-free survival rate. The SWOG trial had less progression with maintenance, although it was defined subjectively as “worsening” disease, which occurred in 87 of 192 patients (45%), substantially more than our objective progression rate of 11% in 5 yr without maintenance BCG. Including our 67 cases undergoing early cystectomy because of “worsening” disease with the 93 “objective” progressors, the overall progression rate using this definition is still lower at 20% among patients not receiving maintenance BCG than those in the SWOG trial.

In an individual patient data meta-analysis of randomized trials comparing intravesical mitomycin C (MMC) with BCG, Malmstrom et al reported a 32% reduction in risk of recurrence on maintenance BCG compared with MMC, and there was a 28% risk increase for BCG without maintenance [19]. However, only 23% of the patients were high risk, and the raw data show that 42.6% of 711 patients recurred on no maintenance compared with 43.2% of 726 patients on BCG maintenance over a median follow-up time of 4.4 yr. The progression rate was 11%, identical to our experience. In another mature trial that included 281 patients (42% high risk) treated with BCG plus maintenance, 37% recurred, 12% progressed, and 5% died of bladder cancer [21]. A third trial reported a 2-yr recurrence-free survival rate of 72% on maintenance, and 10.4% progressed to muscle invasion [22], similar to our results of 73% and 11%, respectively, and a comprehensive review of multiple trials showed 24-mo recurrence-free survival rates varying between 54% and 89% [20]. A recent study comparing BCG maintenance with BCG plus interferon reported 2-yr recurrence-free survival rates of 63% and 55%, respectively [23], which are not superior to our 2-yr or 5-yr results without maintenance BCG.

5. Conclusions

The authors of the studies just cited conclude that maintenance BCG is crucial for efficacy. The raw data in high-risk patients, however, does not seem robust enough to justify such a strong conclusion that every patient should receive maintenance BCG. Admitting that maintenance BCG may prevent a few more recurrences than induction BCG alone, relapsing patients can be salvaged with retreatment rather than exposing all patients to the toxicity associated with maintenance. The important end point of progression in these randomized trials appears to be similar in maintenance and nonmaintenance patients and identical to progression rates in our patients, of whom only a third required retreatment for tumor recurrence. We accept a slightly higher recurrence rate to avoid overtreatment of many patients, and we do not agree that maintenance BCG is necessary to prevent or delay life-threatening tumor progression.

We believe another multicenter prospective randomized trial is needed to settle the issue whether maintenance BCG is truly effective, and we would be glad to participate in such a trial.

Author contributions: Harry W. Herr had full access to all the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis.

Study concept and design: Herr.

Acquisition of data: Herr.

Analysis and interpretation of data: Herr, Dalbagni, Donat.

Drafting of the manuscript: Herr.

Critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content: Herr, Dalbagni, Donat.

Statistical analysis: Herr.

Obtaining funding: None.

Administrative, technical, or material support: Herr.

Supervision: Herr.

Other (specify): None.

Financial disclosures: I certify that all conflicts of interest, including specific financial interests and relationships and affiliations relevant to the subject matter or materials discussed in the manuscript (eg, employment/ affiliation, grants or funding, consultancies, honoraria, stock ownership or options, expert testimony, royalties, or patents filed, received, or pending), are the following: None.

Funding/Support and role of the sponsor: None.


  • [1] A. Morales, D. Eidinger, A.W. Bruce. Intracavitary bacillus Calmette-Guérin in the treatment of superficial bladder tumors. J Urol. 1976;116:180-184
  • [2] D.L. Lamm, D.E. Thor, S.C. Harris, et al. Bacillus Calmette-Guérin immunotherapy of superficial bladder cancer. J Urol. 1980;124:38-43
  • [3] H.W. Herr, C.M. Pinsky, W.F. Whitmore Jr., et al. Effect of intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin on carcinoma in situ of the bladder. Cancer. 1983;51:1323-1326 Crossref.
  • [4] D.L. Lamm, B.A. Blumenstein, E.D. Crawford, et al. A randomized trial of intravesical doxorubicin and immunotherapy with BCG for transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder. New Engl J Med. 1991;325:1205-1209 Crossref.
  • [5] P.U. Malmstrom, H. Wijkstrom, C. Lundholm, et al. 5-year follow-up of a randomized prospective study comparing mitomycin C and BCG in patients with superficial bladder carcinoma. J Urol. 1999;161:1124-1127
  • [6] M. Babjuk, W. Oosterlinck, R. Syvester, et al. EAU guidelines on non-muscle-invasive urothelial carcinoma of the bladder. Eur Urol. 2008;54:303-314 Abstract, Full-text, PDF, Crossref.
  • [7] M.C. Hall, S.S. Chang, G. Dalbagni, et al. Guideline for the management of nonmuscle invasive bladder cancer (stages Ta,T1 and Tis): 2007 update. J Urol. 2007;178:2314-2330 Crossref.
  • [8] J.E. Montie, P.E. Clark, M.A. Eisenberger, et al. National Comprehensive Cancer Network. Bladder cancer. J Natl Compr Canc Netw. 2009;7:8-39
  • [9] D.K. Lamm, B.A. Blunemstein, J.D. Crissman, et al. Maintenance BCG immunotherapy for recurrent TA,T1 and carcinoma in situ transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder: a randomized Southwest Oncology Group Study. J Urol. 2000;163:1124-1129 Crossref.
  • [10] R. Sylvester, A. Van der Meijden, D. Lamm. Intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin reduces the risk of progression in patients with superficial bladder cancer: a meta-analysis of the published results of randomized clinical trials. J Urol. 2002;168:1964-1970
  • [11] H.W. Herr, V.P. Laudone, R.A. Badalament, et al. Bacillus Calmette-Guérin therapy alters progression of superficial bladder cancer. J Clin Oncol. 1988;6:1450-1455
  • [12] H.W. Herr, D.M. Schwalb, Z.-F. Zhang, et al. Intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin therapy prevents tumor progression and death from superficial bladder cancer: ten-year follow-up of a prospective randomized trial. J Clin Oncol. 1995;13:1404-1408
  • [13] R.A. Badalament, H.W. Herr, G.Y. Wong, et al. A prospective randomized trial of maintenance versus nonmaintenance intravesical bacillus Calmette-Guérin therapy of superficial bladder cancer. J Clin Oncol. 1987;5:441-449
  • [14] H.W. Herr. Is maintenance bacillus Calmette-Guérin therapy necessary?. Eur Urol. 2008;54:971-973 Abstract, Full-text, PDF, Crossref.
  • [15] H. Koga, S. Ozono, T. Tsushima, et al. Maintenance intravesical BCG instillation for Ta,T1 cancer and carcinoma in situ of the bladder: randomized controlled trial by the BCG Tokyo strain study group. Int J Urol. 2010;17:759-766 Crossref.
  • [16] Hinotsu S, Akaza H, Naito S, et al. Maintenance therapy with bacillus Calmette-Guérin Connaught strain clearly prolongs recurrence-free survival following transurethral resection of bladder tumor for non-muscle-invasive bladder cancer. BJU Int. In press. DOI:10.1111/j.1464-410X.2010.09891.x.
  • [17] A.Z. Weizer, C. Tallman, J.S. Montgomery. Long-term outcomes of intravesical therapy for non-muscle invasive bladder cancer. World J Urol. 2011;29:59-71 Crossref.
  • [18] A.P.M. van der Meijden, R.J. Sylvester, W. Oosterlinck, et al. Maintenance bacillus Calmette-Guerin for TaT1 bladder tumors is not associated with increased toxicity: results from a European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer Genito-Urinary Group phase III trial. Eur Urol. 2003;44:429-434 Crossref.
  • [19] P.-U. Malmström, R.J. Sylvester, D.E. Crawford, et al. An individual patient data meta-analysis of the long-term outcome of randomised studies comparing intravesical mitomycin C versus bacillus Calmette-Guérin for non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer. Eur Urol. 2009;56:247-256
  • [20] P. Gontero, A. Bohle, P.-U. Malmstrom, et al. The role of bacillus Calmette-Guérin in the treatment of non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer. Eur Urol. 2010;57:410-429 Abstract, Full-text, PDF, Crossref.
  • [21] R.J. Sylvester, M.A. Brausi, W.J. Kirkels, et al. Long-term efficacy results of EORTC Genito-Urinary Group randomized phase 3 study 30911 comparing intravesical instillations of epirubicin, bacillus Calmette-Guérin, and bacillus Calmette-Guérin plus isoniazid in patients with intermediate- and high-risk stage Ta T1 urothelial carcinoma of the bladder. Eur Urol. 2010;57:766-773 Abstract, Full-text, PDF, Crossref.
  • [22] W. Oosterlinck, Z. Kirkali, R. Sylvester, et al. Sequential intravesical chemoimmunotherapy with mitomycin C and bacillus Calmette-Guérin and bacillus Calmette-Guérin alone in patients with carcinoma in situ of the urinary bladder: results of an EORTC phase 2 trial. Eur Urol. 2011;59:438-446 Abstract, Full-text, PDF, Crossref.
  • [23] K.G. Nepple, A.J. Lightfoot, H.M. Rosevear, et al. Bacillus Calmette-Guérin with or without interferon alpha-2b and megadose versus recommended daily allowance vitamins during induction and maintenance intravesical treatment of nonmuscle invasive bladder cancer. J Urol. 2010;184:1915-1919 Crossref.


Department of Urology, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA

lowast Corresponding author. 1275 York Avenue, New York, NY 10021, USA. Tel. +1 646 422 4411; Fax: +1 212 988 0768. Please visit to read and answer questions on-line. The EU-ACME credits will then be attributed automatically.

Place a comment

Your comment *

max length: 5000